How to Make Peanut Butter

While I am typically not a huge fan of peanuts, unless I’m eating them off of a countertop with a pint of beer, I could live quite happily off peanut butter.

A friend of mine who is a chef at a local restaurant forbids bringing peanut butter into his house out of principle. I’ve seen him become red-faced and indignant at the mere mention of it, as he thinks it unsophisticated and barely passable for food, like Cheese Whiz or Twinkies. He may not be alone when it comes to this contentious legume and its creamy spread. Allergies have given peanuts such a bad rap that they are banned from schools and office buildings as if they were something illicit or leprous.  It’s true that they’re not as sexy as the macadamia or as versatile as the almond, and in assorted nut mixtures, they’re always picked last – the fat kid of nuts. But don’t be so quick to judge the lowly peanut.

I always carry a large, Costco-sized container of peanut butter in my cupboard. As a runner, I find it a quick, energy rich food for before or after a workout. As an oft-lazy weeknight cook, I’ll whip together a peanut butter jam sandwich, or will plop down on the couch after work, spoon in hand, and eat directly from the container as if it were a tub of Rocky Road ice cream.

Not from fiscal necessity, but rather out of curiosity, I wanted to see how easy it would be to make my own peanut butter at home.  I’m not  a huge fan of the crunchy, thick stuff they sell in health food stores, so I decided to dispense with the “all natural” and add a bit of sugar and oil for increased taste and added creaminess. The ingredient list is sparse: roasted peanuts, salt, oil and sugar, though if you prefer natural peanut butter perhaps leave out or reduce the last two ingredients.

I picked up a bag of peanuts at the grocery store tonight and felt a little self conscious, like I was buying a Playboy or tampons for a girlfriend. After all, no one buys peanuts anymore except old ladies with purple-dyed hair who feed squirrels in the park.

This recipe couldn’t be more satisfying and was well worth the arched-eyebrow look from the pale-faced cashier tonight. In less than 5 minutes I had a cup full of creamy peanut butter that cost pennies and tasted as good as anything store-bought. Kids, try this at home.

You’ll need:

A food processor

1 cup of roasted, unsalted peanuts – shelled and skinned

¼ tsp of salt

1 1/2 tbsp of peanut, canola or vegetable oil (optional)

1 tbsp of  granulated sugar (this last ingredient is optional and dependent on your taste – I prefer a little sweetness)

Mix all the ingredients together in the food processor for 3 minutes or until the mixture starts to become soft and creamy. Use a spatula to scrape down the sides and then blend again until the desired consistency is reached. You may prefer a bit of chunky peanuts in yours, though I mixed a little longer until smooth. You can also add more or less sugar depending on your taste and hankering for sweets.

After 30 seconds of mixing

After 1 minute....

3 minutes and you're done!

You can eat peanut butter on its own if you’re quirky like me, but it can also be used in a wide range of recipes from pasta, to cookies, to breakfast smoothies as a protein additive. Take a look at my peanut butter dog treats, or quick-and-easy chicken satay. I’ve also made a variation of the classic Phad Thai dish, in which I stir 2 tbsp of PB into cooked rice noodles, along with a dollop of curry paste and a can of coconut milk; sprinkle this with cashews, sliced spring onions and squeezed lime and you’ll get a mouth watering dinner.


About gentlemangourmet

My name is Mike and even though I’m not always a gentleman, it’s safe to say I am in love with food. Like my more famous namesake, the kid on the cereal commercial from the early 80′s, I had an ability to eat just about anything and “like it.” I’ve become a tad more discerning since my toddler phase: I prefer Pinot Noir to the customary Shiraz my parents liked, I no longer eat parmesan cheese sprinkled from a container, and can pick out which ingredients I like or don’t in a recipe by smell alone. I blame my Lebanese heritage, my large Lebanese nose (all the better for smelling with) and exposure over the past few years to some exquisite ethnic cooking styles and cuisine, as well as to some stunning, inspiring cooks who are family or friends. I’ve included a lot of their favourite recipes on this site, as well as a few of my own that have become my staples over the years. I hope you find something here that you like. Happy cooking! View all posts by gentlemangourmet

3 responses to “How to Make Peanut Butter

  • gastoman

    Wow, I was totally with you until I got to the sugar (or for that matter the extra oil). When I eat my favourite store bought PB the ingredient list reads “peanuts”. Its one of those gorgeous foods with one ingredient that is somehow completely different than that ingredient. In any case, I’ll give you the oil and salt but sugar? Really?

    It has been too long since I was on your blog. I have a ton of catching up to do. Glad to see that you are still at it.

    • gentlemangourmet

      Thanks for visiting. I completely understand what you mean about the sugar. There are so many types of peanut butter out there, some healthier than others. Personally, I prefer the creamier, less healthy kind, so I used a bit of oil and sugar. A friend of mine uses confectioner’s sugar, instead of granulated, to make it even creamier. If you’re a fan of the healthy, thicker spread, cut the oil in half and perhaps leave out or reduce the sugar. Personally, I’ve got a sweet tooth that keeps my dentist employed. Mike

  • Foo Dee

    Hello Mike

    I also have not been on in a long while but I had to jump in here. Gastroman is out of line. You have posted a recipe for a sweet and creamy peanut butter. If you don’t like sweet and creamy peanut butter that does not warrant a post about this recipe. It may be the worlds best smooth and creamy peanut butter, he’s still not going to like it but that should take nothing away from another great and practical recipe.

    Time for me to catch up on the rest of the blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: